Sunday, August 17, 2008

Decisions..Learning German or staying sane?

It bothers me that I only speak one language, it bothers me more than I can't even speak the indigenous language of my own country, Maori. It says more about our inherent lingual arrogance that most of us, myself included, will probably never learn it.

Here in the clinic I am surrounded by everyday people who through choice or situation have taken the time and effort to learn not only the language of their estranged homeland, but that of their chosen new home, Germany. Then having settled here and found employment they have taken the time to learn our language because most of us English speaking people cannot be bothered to learn theirs. Instead we believe that the whole world should learn English and things would be so much easier. (for us).

So with that thought in mind I've spent most of the day searching the internet for resources on learning German. One thing that I am seeing over and over again is that just one word might have many meanings, and then there might be half a dozen words to describe the same thing depending on whether it is masculine, feminine or neutral. There are exceptions to every rule, and then there are exceptions to the exceptions. I'd started to think I was inferior and that somehow I lacked the intellect to see the structure of the language and therefore make progress.
Then I stumbled upon an article written in 1880 by the author Mark Twain on the subject of learning German. I have realised I am not alone. Below I have pasted just a small part of that article...

THE AWFUL GERMAN LANGUAGE.

One is sure to lose his temper early; and if he sticks to the subject, and will not be warned, it will at last either soften his brain or petrify it. Personal pronouns and adjectives are a fruitful nuisance in this language, and should have been left out. For instance, the same sound, SIE, means YOU, and it means SHE, and it means HER, and it means IT, and it means THEY, and it means THEM. Think of the ragged poverty of a language which has to make one word do the work of six -- and a poor little weak thing of only three letters at that. But mainly, think of the exasperation of never knowing which of these meanings the speaker is trying to convey. This explains why, whenever a person says SIE to me, I generally try to kill him, if a stranger.

In his parting shots at the German language Twain declares that an intelligent man should be able to learn English in 30 Days, French in 30 months and the basics of German in 30 years.

..I think I'll learn Maori, at least that way I can purge some of my cultural guilt.


PS: Six hours post Chemo and I'm feeling fine :)
The night nurse, Shkoza, performed a blood sugar test (it's a little high), and told me my urine PH was low. So I've had another IV to fix it. That took 30 minutes. (None of these tests have ever been performed on me when getting treatment in NZ!)

It's now 12:30am and I'm off to sleep.

Oh..BTW, Shkoza is replacing Marcus who is on holiday in Croatia for two weeks. Shkoza is a giant of a man who looks like he could be a wrestler if he wanted a career change. Like Marcus he is easy to talk to and very professional.

9 comments:

Anonymous said...

try learning Japanese, they have 3 different alphabets

Anonymous said...

I'm feeling guilty now. Otaki has a high Maori population, many speak Maori as their everyday language and one of our doctors from the USA took the time to have lessons as soon as he got here. I've alway thought about doing the same, but have felt a bit shy in case I couldn't come to grips with it. I'm going to have to think more seriously about doing so.
Glad the chemo hasn't been to horrendous.
Love
Maureen

Anonymous said...

Hi Dude.. great to hear things feeling good. Yes the human condition is a funny thing... when you look at we risk almost without acknowledging it.. then when its all laid in front of us we hestitate??? May have to expalian that more by email..which is?? dont know which one to use? Did you really button your line into your fly!!! Murray

Ron Scanlan said...

Hi Murray,
All my usual email adresses are working. Yes I did button my line into my fly and then try to wash my hands.. I'm slowly loosing my my mind as cabin fever sets in ;)

Anonymous said...

Hi Ron, I am glad that this round of chemo has gone relatively well and that you are in good hands there. It is a worry that the care you are receiving there is so superior to what is provided here in NZ, I would have thought simple blood sugar and PH tests after treatment would be obvious and simple tests to make to see how the body has handled it!!
I hope that you are able to recover quickly and well and that it doesn't knock you about too much.
You are right in your observations about our arrogance at not learning languages and expecting English to be learned and spoken by everyone else, and I confess to not making much effort to learn another language, perhaps I should have continued with the French I learned in school. But which language do you choose, Chinese may be a useful one to learn as they seem to be making their presence felt in the world now, a few years ago it was Japanese. I struggle just to learn music, how on earth would I cope with the Chinese or Japanese characters?
Graham and I enjoy keeping up with you in your bolgs, you have made us laugh even though this is no laughing matter, and it is so good that you keep informed of whats happening to you. We are thinking of you and praying for you all the time.....much love, Karen

Anonymous said...

Hey dad,
German and Maori are fairly alright to learn, shame i don't remember any of it :( lol

xo

Anonymous said...

Maybe this will help you with some german...

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gvj1QGqfQyg


Tim

Ron Scanlan said...

Tim you would not believe this.. I watched that last night. Monty Pyton "And now for something completely different".

Anonymous said...

That is really unbelievable, like the jigsaw and nibbler?
I was thinking it is probably not politically correct to have John Cleese on your screen doing his German walk. Tim